23.06.2020
Mammoth tusks are priceless finds. “Black archaeologists” in search of mammoth tusks Where to look for mammoth tusks
Do not forget that the exclusive right to publish the article belongs to me. When reprinting, please cite the author and ask permission...
Smugglers earn about a billion rubles from selling the remains of mammoths found in Yakutia. In the Arctic territories, according to officials, about 500 thousand tons of bones of ancient animals can be found. So far, their production is poorly controlled: at least a quarter of the turnover comes from the shadow market. Because of this, the budget, the residents of the North, and scientists are losing money.
Illegals are in a hurry
The rules for collecting mammoth remains must be spelled out in legislation as soon as possible, Nikolai Nikolaev, head of the State Duma Committee on Natural Resources, Property and Land Relations, said on June 26. The draft bill was developed in Yakutia, where over 80% of the so-called mammoth fauna. The document is now being studied by the Ministry of Natural Resources and Rosnedra.
Parliamentarians of the Far Eastern republic propose to regulate the extraction of mammoth remains not within the framework of the law “On Subsoil”, as is happening now, but to create a separate document - “On the rational use of resources of the mammoth fauna - special natural resource Russia." “I agree with my colleagues that it is necessary to provide commercial collection areas mammoth bone“said the chairman of the relevant State Duma committee.
He added that it is necessary to centralize all sales and establish an examination of the extracted remains so that exhibits of scientific value do not go to the market. Nikolaev hastened the adoption of the bill, the discussion of which has been dragging on for at least a dozen years: “They (black diggers. - Approx..
About 100 tons of mammoth ivory are mined annually in Yakutia. About 30%, according to regional authorities, comes from the shadow market. According to other estimates, the share of smuggling reaches 50%. And the business is quite profitable: 50 kg of mammoth ivory on the official market costs about $15 thousand, on the black market its price can double.
The former head of Yakutia, Yegor Borisov, emphasized that this area is becoming increasingly criminal. “Mammoth fauna has become a fairly traded industry, because in world practice a moratorium on ivory mining has been declared,” he explained. It's about on a partial ban on the ivory trade due to declining elephant populations in Asia and Africa, which the UN introduced in 2002.
The Yakut parliament also paid attention to another problem. With a twofold increase in the issuance of licenses for the industrial collection of mammoth tusks, the regional budget does not receive any taxes from this activity.
Tusk under the jacket
According to Yakut scientists, every year illegal mining of bones of ancient animals brings businessmen over 1 billion rubles. Over the past decade, searchers have destroyed seven cemeteries containing the remains of ancient animals. “The scale of vandalism shown in relation to the nature of the Arctic, its unique monuments - paleontological, geological, archaeological - by participants in illegal amateur mining of mammoth tusks is enormous,” said Vladimir Pitulko, an archaeologist, head of the Yana-Indigirka expedition of the Institute of the History of Material Culture of the Russian Academy of Sciences, in an interview with TASS .
In February, a Yakut company, using forged documents, tried to take out of Russia (presumably to China, where most of the remains go) over 4.5 tons of mammoth tusks - this is a record batch detained by the FSB border department in the Primorsky Territory. The containers contained more than 650 fragments of remains, 14 of which were museum-level valuables. The total amount of smuggled cargo was estimated at more than 340 million rubles.
In March last year, a resident of the Amur region tried to hide under outerwear a fragment of mammoth bone weighing 10 kg and worth over 400 thousand rubles. The attacker was caught, and the court sentenced him to three years probation.
The most big story happened in 2010. Then two Russians established the largest channel for exporting tusks bought from black diggers from Russia. Over the course of several years, the men sold over 100 tons of remains abroad, earning about $50 million. They were caught at a customs checkpoint near Vyborg when they were transporting a shipment of 2.8 tons worth $1 million. Ultimately, they were sentenced to eight years on 72 counts of smuggling conditionally.
Smugglers in search of profit cause serious harm to the environment Arctic territory. To quickly find the remains, they use heat and water cannons, which destroys not only the shores, but also the permafrost. In addition to the fact that illegal fishing harms nature, it also deprives scientists of the most valuable specimens of the remains of ancient animals for studying. “The Republic is losing its monopoly on Scientific research unique fossil objects and income from exhibiting them at commercial exhibitions,” said First Deputy Minister of Education and Science of Yakutia Mikhail Prisyazhny.
The head of the department for the study of mammoth fauna of the Academy of Sciences of the Republic, Albert Protopopov, estimates financial losses from smuggling at 1.5 billion rubles annually, scientific losses are incalculable in money. “Tusk hunters throw away bones, skeletons and other scientifically valuable artifacts. How much could be done scientific discoveries, if these data were studied,” the scientist complains.
Mammoths = oil
From 1991 to 2002, the industrial collection of tusks in the Arctic territory of Yakutia was not licensed. Before this, the entire industry was tied to the National Mammoth Fund, which regulated both the collection and processing of these resources. Licenses began to be issued in 2003. Tribal communities can receive it, individual entrepreneurs And legal entities. Initially, they were issued for a year, but from 2016 the period was increased to five years. The only condition is that you can only collect those remains that are on the surface. The relevant authorities of the region together with the branch are responsible for issuing licenses Federal agency on subsoil use.
According to the Ministry of Industry and Geology of the Republic, at the end of 2017, 509 licenses were in force, of which only two were for the collection of remains for scientific purposes, the rest for the sale of goods. A boom in obtaining licenses occurred in 2016, when their validity period was increased. Then more than 430 of them were issued (for comparison, last year - 78). To obtain a license, you need to pay a state fee of 7.5 thousand rubles - in comparison with the amounts that can be earned from selling tusks, these are ridiculous figures. However, fines for illegal mining are even less - 3 thousand rubles.
Yakut authorities, social activists and scientists have been saying for more than ten years that a separate the federal law. The regional one was not enough; the republic already had such experience: in 2005, the President of Yakutia Vyacheslav Shtyrov signed a law regulating the industry, but two years later its effect was suspended by the prosecutor’s office.
Five years ago, a deputy from the republic, Fedot Tumusov, submitted to the State Duma a bill recognizing the remains of mammoths as a mineral along with oil and gas. The parliamentarian essentially proposed recognizing cemeteries of remains as deposits and levying a mining tax on collectors. The relevant State Duma committee found contradictions with the Constitution in the bill and sent it for revision.
In the near future, another bill regulating the extraction of remains will be considered by the lower house of parliament. On the commercial side, regional authorities have already begun to act to restore order. At the beginning of the year, Yakutia Minister of Investment Development and Entrepreneurship Anton Safronov said that officials had agreed with Chinese partners to create a single operator for the collection, processing and export of mammoth tusks.
One of the options is to build a logistics and production complex within the Yakut priority development territory (TOR) Kangalassy. Its cost is estimated at 1.3 billion rubles. According to Safronov, the creation of a single operator will help establish order in pricing. “Now the price is at a minimum. There are a huge number of sellers on the market, including from shadow businesses, which leads to dumping of the cost of exported goods,” he explained.
Family business
The Russian-Chinese project, according to the minister, will increase the volume of extraction of the remains of ancient animals, and therefore create at least 2 thousand seasonal jobs. Entire villages are now engaged in mining mammoth bones. In the North, where there are few jobs and prices are many times higher than in the capital due to logistical difficulties, collecting remains is the most quick way earn money.
“The entire coast of the Laptev Sea in northern Yakutia has long been divided between communities that have been collecting mammoth tusks for several decades, and it is simply impossible to get there. You need to have connections,” says mammoth tusk hunter Alexander Popov. “People work in whole teams of 15–20 people.”
Preparing such an expedition requires large financial investments - at least half a million rubles. To do this, local residents sometimes have to mortgage all their hard-earned property, including real estate. It is impossible to predict success: it may also happen that the seekers leave with nothing after two months of hiking in difficult conditions.
Majority local residents works without licenses. Supervisory authorities primarily fight against resellers who establish illegal channels for exporting tusks abroad. On average, smugglers export from Russia at least 60 tons of valuable goods per year - in other words, they already have their work cut out for them.
A couple of months ago I was in Perm and visited there, and so, they told a lot and showed mammoth bones and tusks, and there I heard for the first time that there is a whole illegal industry - the search for mammoth tusks.
American photographer Amos Chapple spent three weeks in the company of “black archaeologists” who are searching for the remains of mammoths in the Siberian forests. These people spend the whole summer in forests and swamps, trying to find the remains of ancient animals and, most importantly, find their tusks. This activity is illegal, so diggers have to avoid encounters with police and environmental services, as well as put up with difficult living conditions in the forest. But all this is compensated by the high cost of tusks. On the black market, a 65-kilogram mammoth ivory can fetch $34,000. There have been cases where groups of diggers managed to earn about $100,000 in a week of searching.
Photo 2.
Let's see what it looks like:
Photo 3.
The tusks of ancient mammoths are extremely valuable for scientists and archaeologists, but for the most part, they disappear without a trace on the black market.
No one knows how many mammoths are imprisoned in the land of Siberia. As a rule, every discovery of the remains of an ancient animal causes a sensation in scientific circles. Scientists to this day have not given up hope of cloning an amazing animal, but, alas, the state of the biomaterial of the found “mineral resource” does not meet the standards required for such a procedure.
Photo 4.
Every year in Siberia, illegal miners pull several tons of tusks from captivity in permafrost. Despite the hard physical labor and the illegality of the process, the game is worth the candle - for a kilogram of mammoth tusk you can earn somewhere between 20-25 thousand rubles. Wherein average weight one tusk - about 50 kilograms.
Mammoth bone is so expensive because good qualities, far superior to the quality of ivory. Previously, carvers used found tusks to create combs, boxes, and sculptures. The material is very plastic, beautiful and durable. In China, sculptures carved from the bone of an ancient animal are highly valued. Usually, tusks from the black market are sent there.
Photo 5.
Since every year the tusks are gradually removed from the ground, there are fewer and fewer of them, and the work of the miners becomes more and more difficult. They can be located at the bottom of a swamp or river, or very deep underground and in ice. In addition, due to ancient superstitions, the indigenous peoples of the North have to sacrifice something to the local spirits in order to take the find without any consequences.
Photo 6.
There is a law on criminal liability for "black archaeologists". For illegal seizure of archaeological objects and evasion of the mandatory transfer of discovered artifacts to the state, they face up to six years in prison.
“The law “On Subsoil” says that it is forbidden (to dig), but “black archaeologists” - there is already such a term in science - “bomb”, especially in the north. There was no order with archeology either, the responsibility was minimal, responsibility for paleontology no at all. Even during the construction of objects, archaeological conclusions are mandatory, but paleontological ones are not, everything is at the discretion of the owner.
There are a lot of cases of looting in Siberia. There is a sales market, it is established. You can go to the Internet, enter “I’ll buy a treasury sword”, “I’ll buy mammoth tusks” - and a bunch of offers will come up. And nine out of 10 it will be without any documents. Products and skeletons are very expensive. And even then they make documents, legalize them, and sell them to museums.
Photo 7.
A banal example is the Krasnoyarsk Kurya in the Teguldetsky district Tomsk region. There, for several years in a row, there was an intensified robbery by “black paleontologists” of the location of mammoths, which, as it later turned out, was combined with archaeological finds.
There are hundreds of thousands square meters were dug up to extract mammoth bones. They dug even in winter. What came across in parallel - evidence of the Paleolithic era (stones, processed bones) - was destroyed and lost. And it seems like, according to the descriptions of the local population, there were hearths with charcoal of ancient people. Everything is destroyed irrevocably. This is a typical example of a large scale.
Therefore, the same tightening of the law must be introduced in relation to paleontology. Many archaeological sites contain animal bones, and vice versa. Paleontological and archaeological objects need to be “combined.”
Photo 8.
But what I still don’t understand is how they know where to wash, and especially into the depths of the slope. They burnt and wash away all the slopes along the river, especially since the tusks are often in the depths.
Photo 9.
Photo 10.
Photo 11.
Photo 12.
Photo 13.
Photo 14.
Photo 15.
Photo 16.
Photo 17.
Photo 18.
Photo 19.
Photo 20.
Photo 21.
Photo 22.
Photo 23.
Photo 24.
Photo 25.
Photo 26.
Photo 27.
Photo 28.
Photo 29.
Photo 30.
Photo 31.
Photo 32.
Photo 33.
Photo 34.
Photo 35.
Photo 36.
Photo 37.
Photo 38.
Photo 39.
sources
Mammoth ivory is in demand all over the world. Russia has a fairly large reserve of this material. It numbers about several hundred tons. Despite such a huge number, archaeologists do not stop, but continue to look for where to find
Are there frequent cases of successful excavations aimed at finding mammoth bones?
Every year the warehouse is replenished by approximately several tens of tons. A wide variety of finds were found. Of these, the largest can be distinguished: their length is 4-4.5 meters, diameter 1.8-1.9 decimeters.
A mammoth tusk can weigh 0.1-0.11 tons. In Africa, researchers found this part of an elephant skeleton, which weighed 0.095 tons.
Mammoth bone rests near bodies of water
Where does the extraction of mammoth tusks take place? As a rule, they are dug up near former reservoirs, because the animals were drawn to sources of moisture. You can also stumble upon a mammoth tusk somewhere in a ravine or deep on a river bottom.
The Siberian region is extremely rich in this artifact, because the North is a very favorable habitat for the animal, where it did not feel hot in a thick and dense fur coat. Siberia bestows the scientific light of archeology with thousands of mammoth tusks. More precisely, about 20,000-35,000 kilograms are found annually.
Russia - home of mammoths
Studying the statistics, you can catch yourself thinking that on the lands of today’s Russia, mammoths really liked it, and it was more than comfortable, because the number of finds is simply amazing in its abundance. Moreover, not only the northern part of Siberia was their home, as it might seem at first glance.
The nineteenth and twentieth centuries were rich in mammoth ivory. The overwhelming number of successful excavations took place in the Ob region and Yakutia. Thus, it is clear why the Yakuts and Tobolsk people held products made from mammoth ivory in such esteem.
Craftsmen created small sculptures, boxes, watch stands, and combs. These things were made entirely of bone. Everyone wanted to decorate their neck with such a thing as an amulet made from mammoth ivory.
The land on which the glorious city of Arkhangelsk now stands is also famous for its fertility of archaeological values. They also made jewelry and objects that were used in everyday life from mammoth ivory. They were performed by skilled Kholmogory craftsmen.
Extraction of a valuable artifact
Getting mammoth ivory is interesting and profitable occupation, however, not easy. The river bottom is the most frequent place location of this material. Either it is a swamp or tundra. In a word, you won’t be able to get away with it in the literal sense of the word. And you will have to get your hands dirty, but for what purpose! Extraction is only half the battle. When an artifact seeker is happy with a find, he is faced with the following task: now these raw materials also need to be delivered to a processing point. During construction and archaeological excavations, and also when geological surveys are carried out, you can really stumble upon a mammoth tusk. The photo gives an idea of what sizes and shapes they have.
This often happens in Chukotka, northern Yakutia, and Tyumen lands. Since bone carving was a folk art and was popular in the northern part of Russia, which is part of Europe, and in Siberia until the twentieth century, many examples of masterful processing of mammoth ivory have accumulated.
What bones are suitable for work?
There are no special requirements or strict conditions that would limit the freedom in choosing a material that will later be turned into a beautiful product. The bone can be chosen at your discretion.
The following types of materials were mainly used:
- moose, cows and deer are quite suitable for processing. They are durable and products made from them last a long time. You can take the horn of any ungulate animal.
- Not only horns are suitable for these purposes. Camels, cows and horses have good tubular tibias that can be safely used. The main condition is that the animal must be large and have ungulates.
- Mammoths and elephants are excellent “suppliers” of tusks for further artistic processing.
- The sperm whale is also a potential “supplier” of bone, and to be precise, its tooth is valuable.
- Walruses can give considerable competition with their tusks.
- The rhinoceros is an animal that can truly be proud of what gapes on its forehead. In the same way, every craftsman is proud when he gets the horn of this strong animal into his hands for processing.
- Narwhal is another individual whose bone is ideal for making beautiful and useful products.
What are the restrictions?
There are regulations, the text of which includes restrictions or even prohibits the sale of horns of animals such as narwhal and rhinoceros. The sale of sperm whale teeth is also limited.
Since 2002, the UN has partially banned the trade in elephant ivory. What then is legal? Mammoth tusks can be sold, and the sale of artiodactyl horns is also permitted. These bans are introduced in order to prevent the brutal killing of animals for profit, so this does not apply to the long-extinct mammoths, because they have not been among them for 10 thousand years existing species fauna representatives. Their bone can be safely used and exported. The only, but important detail: it is necessary to draw up a document permitting production and export abroad.
But still, working with a mammoth tusk is much easier than with ivory or walrus tusk. These are justified restrictions that prevent damage to nature and insure animal world from poaching. Fortunately, there are still many rivers in Siberia, in the soil of which mammoth bones rest, so that living elephants can calmly nibble grass at a watering hole and not worry too much.
Benefits of mammoth tusks
They are deservedly valued above all other similar substitutes. This material is plastic and beautiful. But you have to pay for it, so it is rated higher. It is not so easy to process, but it serves conscientiously and for a long time.
This material is continuous, there is very little void in it, the mass can be considered almost homogeneous. Since the dimensions can be very large, there is the possibility of carving a large sculpture. In order to process a mammoth tusk, you need a chisel. When cut, the sculptor will see a pattern made of a beautiful mesh. Appearance The product is very effective, whatever the processing method. The artifact is painted, polished and engraved. We know about the hardness of amber, pearls and coral. So, mammoth bone is in no way inferior to them.
Analogues and substitutes
If we talk about the tarsus, it has a tubular structure. And here the sculptor has less scope for the scope of his imagination. Some carvers prefer it because it costs less. Russians most often use the tarsus of a cow, while Asians borrow this material from camels. There are also craftsmen who, thanks to their skill, pass off a cheap substitute as mammoth tusk. Although a trained eye will notice the difference in no time.
It has a yellowish or brown heterogeneous color. One-year-old rings can be seen on the tusk. You may have seen something similar on a cross-section of a wooden trunk. So be extremely careful when buying products made from mammoth ivory. To protect yourself from purchasing a counterfeit, consult with professionals. This will avoid wasting money.
In chapter
Dmitry Medvedev instructed Deputy Prime Minister Alexei Gordeev to look into the situation with the extraction of fossil mammoth bones. He, in turn, gathered officials from the Ministry of Natural Resources and Rosnedra, as well as market participants, for a meeting. It’s even strange that the government did not worry about the “mammoth” problem earlier, because the mammoth ivory market is now completely opaque.
Russia may not be the birthplace of elephants, but it is certainly their last refuge. Scientists have reliably established that the last herds of mammoths lived on Wrangel Island about three and a half thousand years ago. Today, mammoth bone cemeteries are found everywhere - in France, the Czech Republic, and Ukraine. But only where the earth has been in a state of permafrost for thousands of years is the mammoth tusk preserved in its original form.
Today it is the only highly valuable bone material permitted for extraction and use. Elephant tusks have long been transferred to the category of forbidden materials, similar decisions were made regarding the sperm whale tooth (due to the complete abandonment of whale hunting) and walrus tusk (harvested northern peoples in small quantities). That’s why mammoth bone is so valuable. One of the largest mammoth burial grounds in the world is Yakutia (80% of the world reserve). According to experts, in the North Yakutsk bone-bearing province, potential reserves of mammoth ivory could be about 500 thousand tons, their value exceeds $1.5 billion. Today in Russia it is impossible to mine mammoth ivory: it can only be collected where it comes to the surface on its own. This activity is regulated by the Law “On Subsoil” (collection of mineralogical collections). Licenses issued by regional authorities are a kind of ticket to a multimillion-dollar market. They allow you to legalize any volume of illegally extracted bone - if only there was a sale.
For 20 years the government of Yakutia has been convincing federal center give the region control and supervisory powers in the area of mammoth ivory turnover. At the same time, the Yakuts are trying to monopolize the buying market. The motivation is good - “black digging” is flourishing, taxes are not paid, products are exported duty-free to China. However, in reality, Yakut clans are fighting each other for access to “first-class” products - the most valuable specimens of tusks.
Prices and varieties
The most valuable is considered to be a completely preserved mammoth tusk that has no external damage. As a rule, collectible tusks are rarely used for bone carving; they are very beautiful in themselves, and are either given to museums or used as interior decoration. Paired tusks of one animal are especially valued.
Only “first grade” is suitable for sculptural carving. It includes whole tusks, as well as perfectly preserved fragments of tusks that do not have cracks or other visible defects inside. Mammoth bone sculptures are especially prized in China. By the way, Prime Minister Medvedev also likes products made from mammoth bone, and they are present in his office. There are only a few real cutting masters in Russia; orders are not placed with them. last people. Complex sculptures can cost from a million rubles.
The so-called wood chips (small bones and fragments of large bones) are sold to resellers for pennies - 25 rubles per kilogram. For example, you can make various crafts from it. More liquid material – well-preserved tusks, individual large bones – is valued much more expensively. Here the price can vary from 2 thousand rubles to infinity, it all depends on the quality of the material.
It is noteworthy that the mammoth had only four teeth: two at the top and two on the lower jaw. The upper (chewing) part of the tooth is a kind of grater, with which he ground grass, small branches and leaves. Previously, mammoth teeth were practically not used for bone carving, since they are difficult to process and crumble. Today, mammoth teeth, after certain processing, are widely used by knifemakers in the Scandinavian countries.
"Black paleontologists"
These people spend the entire summer in forests and swamps, trying to find the remains of ancient animals and, most importantly, find their tusks. This activity is illegal, so diggers have to avoid encounters with police and environmental services, as well as put up with difficult living conditions in the forest. But all this is compensated by the high cost of tusks. On our black market, a 65-kilogram mammoth tusk somehow fetched $34,000. There were cases when groups of diggers managed to earn about 100 thousand dollars in a week of searching.
The tusks of ancient mammoths are extremely valuable for scientists and archaeologists, but most of them disappear without a trace on the black market. The tusks, carefully packed in plastic film, fly to Yakutsk, from where they are sent to China.
The cargo, of course, is unofficial. On the Chinese black market, the price for such bones starts from 35 thousand dollars for each tusk. But only 20–30% of “black paleontologists” will succeed. For most diggers, a whole summer of hellish work in the dirt will only be a waste of time and money (often they take out enslaving loans). Many people only get ordinary dice, which are worth nothing.
In general, the extraction of mammoth bones is very destructive for environment. Both licensees and “black paleontologists” mercilessly erode the banks of Yakut rivers with the help of motor pumps. But it is not only the environment that is being barbarously destroyed. Thus, on the territory of the Tomsk region, a huge cemetery of mammoths (more than 5 thousand square meters) and sites of ancient people were recently found. As a result, “black paleontologists” organized a whole pilgrimage here. Thousands of square meters of soil were dug up to extract mammoth bones. They dug even in winter. What came across in parallel - evidence of the Paleolithic era (stones and bones processed by ancient people) - was destroyed and lost. According to descriptions of the local population, there were hearths with charcoal of ancient people. Everything is destroyed irrevocably. Such barbarity, of course, requires punishment to the fullest extent of the law. But the laws are not written.
Licensing issues
It is interesting that Fyodor Shidlovsky, the founder of Nash LLC, was present at the meeting with Alexey Gordeev glacial period"and the largest trader of VIP products made from mammoth ivory in Moscow. He and other major players are not against legally mining bone at depths of over 6 meters. This will make it possible to increase its annual exports by 10 times - up to 1 thousand tons per year, increasing income by 12-13 billion rubles. Fortunately, China due to the trade ban elephant tusk ready to absorb the entire volume of mammoth bone from Yakutia.
However, it is almost impossible to estimate the actual reserves of mammoth ivory in the bowels of Russia. It is also impossible to estimate the starting amount of payment for the use of subsoil for the purpose of extracting mammoth ivory. Because the price of the final product depends more on the skill of the carver than on the quality of the raw materials.
At a meeting with Deputy Prime Minister Alexei Gordeev, “they discussed the possibility of legislatively classifying subsoil plots containing mammoth ivory as subsoil plots of local importance, providing them for use through auctions, establishing regular payments for this type of subsoil use and ensuring the sale of mammoth ivory and products made from it at organized auctions,” noted Gordeev’s representative.
“A significant part of the locations of mammoth tusks is located in the coastal, including underwater, zone of the seas of the North Arctic Ocean, as well as on islands classified as shelf zone Russian Federation. However, currently mammoth bone an independent species is not a mineral resource and calculation of reserves and assessment of predicted resources are not carried out,” the Deputy Prime Minister said.
In a word, some kind of legislative dead end. The problem with the extraction of mammoth bones can age, like the mammoth tusks themselves, but remain unresolved? The meeting participants conceptually supported the possibility of establishing in the subsoil legislation a new type of subsoil use - the collection of mineralogical, paleontological and other geological materials as ornamental raw materials for commercial purposes. However, such a fee may be paid.
Gordeev also gave instructions to speed up the formation of the Ministry of Natural Resources of the Russian Federation working group, which will develop solutions to improve legislation in the field of extraction and circulation of fossil mammoth ivory. Perhaps this group will finally come up with something worthwhile.